
Do I have a case that's worth my time and effort?
To be successful in any court you must have at least one valid legal ground and admissible evidence to support your side. Only a handful of states allows you to request a jury trial so you will likely be standing before a judge who will be looking at the legal issue and not the emotional drama behind the scenes.
- Breach of Contract. The first thing to do is read the agreement or contract carefully. Did the Airline violate the contract in any way? Read the fine print on your ticket and read the airline's General Conditions of Carriage. Did the airline make representations to you that are not referenced in the printed terms and conditions? Are they written anywhere else on the contract? In most cases a verbal promise is difficult to prove and may not be binding as most contracts have a clause which states that the printed terms and conditions constitute the "entire agreement between the Buyer and Seller and no other promises or representations of any kind are binding on the Seller. In a Breach of Contract claim a clear-cut violation of the contract is the strongest case.
- Statutory Violation.The airline may violate a statute whether federal or state. When a statute has been violated, particularly strict liability statutes, the airline will have no leg to stand on. The violation of a statute will be the best cause you have. Go to Federal Trade Commission, State Laws and Department of Transportation website for a review of the most common laws that are broken that will help you in Small Claims Court. All judges like cases with clear-cut legal points that make the decision easy.
Before you file any case you must decide if it will be worth your time and effort. In Small Claims Court you are the client, the attorney, and the investigator rolled into one. You may have to file in another city or state. So the time and expense in traveling will be a factor. You will have to do legal research to find the applicable caselaw. You will have to gather all relevant documents and find supporting witnesses when appropriate. You will have to prepare your oral arguments for the judge and be able, if allowed in the jurisdiction, to examine and cross-examine witnesses and the defendant.
Next